{
  "rows": [
    [
      "OLDER METHODOLOGY",
      "Risk Matrix & Methodology [Old]",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "RA Scope and boundaries",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Connected and software-defined road vehicles\nOther vulnerable road users and owners/occupants\nMobile apps\nOEM and supplier backends like cloud/AI services\nLong range external communications V2X/GNSS/cellular/satellite links\nEV charging/V2G\nRoadside and traffic-management systems\nOther relevant dependencies with other domain/sectors",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Scope of Timing",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "From the Cybersecurity regulation Implementation till current state of the art including the attack feasibility through large frontier models used for large scale vehicle hacking. ",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Threat actors",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Cybercriminals, opportunists, insiders, hacktivists, capable organized groups, suppliers, and state-aligned actors. Capability and motivation vary by threat.",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Exposure and controls Assumptions",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Internet exposure, wireless communication(short and long range), physical access, services online and offline, supply-chain, and privileged-access exposure etc. Baseline Standard industry best practice controls are assumed, but effectiveness is bvery subjective. Cannot be generalized. No residual risk is scored.",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Likelihood interpretation",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Probability is very subjective and means likelihood that the threat successfully realizes within scope. Look at the rationale but it is not standardized and difficult to score.",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Limitations",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "This is a very high level workshop based assessment on stated threats by the working group and a hybrid methodology, not a system-specific TARA, penetration test or quantified probability model.\nSystem-specific architecture, fleet exposure, control effectiveness and incident telemetry were not provided. Rating is structured expert judgement; validate during system-specific TARA.",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Impact definitions (tailored criteria, not one-to-one to referred frameworks)",
      "",
      "",
      "Likelihood definitions",
      "",
      "",
      "Risk matrix (Impact x Likelihood)",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Impact",
      "Score",
      "Definition",
      "Likelihood",
      "Score",
      "Definition",
      "Impact / Likelihood",
      "Rare (1)",
      "Low (2)",
      "Medium (3)",
      "High (4)"
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Severe",
      4,
      "Credible fatalities/multiple serious injuries, loss of safety-critical control, or widespread/prolonged disruption with major cascading societal or critical-infrastructure effects; very difficult recovery.",
      "High",
      4,
      "Successful materialisation is expected or repeatedly plausible within three years given exposure, available techniques, incentives, and control uncertainty.",
      "Low (1)",
      "Low",
      "Low",
      "Low",
      "Moderate?"
    ],
    [
      "",
      "High",
      3,
      "Major safety, operational, privacy, or financial harm; multiple assets/users or substantial service disruption; coordinated recovery required.",
      "Medium",
      3,
      "Successful materialisation is plausible within three years but depends on exploitable weaknesses, access, scale, or control gaps.",
      "Medium (2)",
      "Low",
      "Moderate",
      "Moderate",
      "Moderate"
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Medium",
      2,
      "Material but bounded harm; localized disruption or privacy/financial impact; recovery is feasible with established processes.",
      "Low",
      2,
      "Successful harmful outcome is possible but requires uncommon access, significant resources, coordination, or several control failures.",
      "High (3)",
      "Low",
      "Moderate",
      "High?",
      "High?"
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Low",
      1,
      "Limited direct harm or mainly governance/efficiency impact; short duration, few assets, straightforward recovery.",
      "Rare",
      1,
      "Exceptional conditions are required and successful materialisation is not reasonably expected within the horizon; retain as a scenario.",
      "Severe (4)",
      "Moderate?",
      "Moderate",
      "High?",
      "Critical"
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Severe",
      4,
      "",
      "High",
      4,
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "High",
      3,
      "",
      "Medium",
      3,
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Medium",
      2,
      "",
      "Low",
      2,
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Low",
      1,
      "",
      "Rare",
      1,
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Risk-level definitions and calculation",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Risk Level",
      "Product Range",
      "Interpretation",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Critical",
      "Score product 9-16",
      "Urgent treatment, senior ownership, and cross-stakeholder coordination.",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "High",
      "6-8",
      "Prioritized treatment and accountable action plan.",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Moderate",
      "3-4",
      "Planned mitigation, monitoring, and reassessment.",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Low",
      "1-2",
      "Monitor or accept within explicit risk appetite.",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "Formula logic",
      "Impact and likelihood text are converted by XLOOKUP to scores. Risk Level = IF(product>=9,\"Critical\", IF(product>=6,\"High\", IF(product>=3,\"Moderate\",\"Low\"))). Scores are ordinal decision aids, not measured probabilities.",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "Updated Framework: Leidraad Risicobeoordeling Rijksbrede Risico Analyze Nationale Veiligheid",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "National security interests and impact criteria",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "No.",
      "National security dimensions",
      "Impact criteria",
      "Typical examples/evidences",
      "Applicable?",
      "Criterion score A-E",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      1,
      "Territorial security",
      "1.1 Territory\n1.2 International position\n1.3 Digital space\n1.4 Allied territory??",
      "Loss of control, affected organizations, vital infra providers, scale, motive, duration",
      "See highlighted",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      2,
      "Physical safety",
      "2.1 Deaths\n2.2 Serious injuries/chronic illness\n2.3 Primary needs",
      "Fatalities, serious injuries, emergency-care impact, essential-services interruption",
      "See highlighted ",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      3,
      "Economic security",
      "3.1 Costs\n3.2 Economic vitality",
      "Direct/indirect damage, cost recovery, lost income, sector breadth and duration",
      "See highlighted ",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      4,
      "Ecological security",
      "4.1 Long-term environment and nature damage",
      "Affected area, protected ecosystems, duration, reversibility",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      5,
      "Social and political stability",
      "5.1 Daily life disruption\n5.2 Democratic rule of law impairment\n5.3 Societal impact\n5.4 Privacy [from ISO/SAE 21434:2021]",
      "Population affected, duration, mobility/access restrictions, institutional or structural societal effects",
      "See highlighted ",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      6,
      "International legal order and stability",
      "6.1 Sovereignty; \n6.2 Human rights; \n6.3 Rules-based economic order; \n6.4 Multilateral institutions; \n6.5 Neighbouring-state stability",
      "State involvement, norm breach, scale, duration, affected institutions/states",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "Impact Scale ",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "Class",
      "Score",
      "Label",
      "National-security interpretation",
      "Questions for assessment? Mobility context",
      "Evidence expectation or straightforward",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "A",
      1,
      "Limited",
      "Limited impairment of one applicable criterion.",
      "Limited direct harm or mainly local impact,\nshort duration, \nfew assets or people, \nstraightforward recovery.\n",
      "?",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "B",
      2,
      "Significant",
      "Significant but contained impairment of one or more criteria.",
      "Noticeable harm beyond routine operations,\nmultiple users/assets or localized service impact,\nrecovery requires managed intervention.",
      "?",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "C",
      3,
      "Serious",
      "At least one criterion reaches serious national-security impact.",
      "Safety, operational, privacy, financial or societal harm but not widespread \nLocalized or sector-limited disruption\nCoordinated recovery",
      "?",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "D",
      4,
      "Very serious",
      "At least one criterion reaches very serious impact.",
      "Major safety, operational, privacy or economic harm\nMultiple organizations/sectors \nProlonged disruption\nDifficult and multi-party recovery.",
      "?",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "E",
      5,
      "Catastrophic",
      "At least one criterion reaches catastrophic impact.",
      "Mass casualties or severe safety consequences?\nLoss of control of vital systems?\nWidespread prolonged national disruption?\nRecovery extremely difficult?",
      "?",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "Likelihood scale",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "Class",
      "Score",
      "Label",
      "Probability in 5 years",
      "Questions for assessment of likelihood? Mobility context interpretation",
      "Logic for interpretation or Evidence",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "A",
      1,
      "Very unlikely",
      "<0.05%",
      "Exceptional; the harmful scenario is not reasonably expected.",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "B",
      2,
      "Unlikely",
      "0.05%-0.5%",
      "Possible only under uncommon conditions or several failures.",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "C",
      3,
      "Somewhat likely",
      "0.5%-5%",
      "Plausible given credible hazards, exposure or controllability.",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "D",
      4,
      "Likely",
      "5%-50%",
      "Repeatedly plausible or expected under the assessed conditions.",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "E",
      5,
      "Very likely",
      "50%-100%",
      "Expected or frequent during the horizon.",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "Risk Scale ",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "Impact / Likelihood",
      "Very unlikely A (1)",
      "Unlikely B (2)",
      "Somewhat likely C (3)",
      "Likely D (4)",
      "Very likely E (5)",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "Catastrophic E (5)",
      "5 - Moderate",
      "10 - High",
      "15 - High",
      "20 - Critical",
      "25 - Critical",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "Very serious D (4)",
      "4 - Low",
      "8 - Moderate",
      "12 - High",
      "16 - High",
      "20 - Critical",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "Serious C (3)",
      "3 - Low",
      "6 - Moderate",
      "9 - Moderate",
      "12 - High",
      "15 - High",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "Significant B (2)",
      "2 - Low",
      "4 - Low",
      "6 - Moderate",
      "8 - Moderate",
      "10 - High",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ],
    [
      "Limited A (1)",
      "1 - Low",
      "2 - Low",
      "3 - Low",
      "4 - Low",
      "5 - Moderate",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      "",
      ""
    ]
  ]
}